Shingles vs Metal Roofing:
Which is Right for You?
A comprehensive comparison to help Illinois homeowners choose between asphalt shingles and metal roofing.
Choose Shingles If...
Budget is your priority, you want classic curb appeal, or you plan to sell within 15 years.
Choose Metal If...
You want maximum durability, long-term savings, or plan to stay in your home for 20+ years.
Head-to-Head Comparison
For a typical 1,500 sq ft roof. Metal costs 2-3x more initially.
Metal can last 2-3x longer, potentially making it cheaper long-term.
Metal withstands extreme weather, hail, and high winds better.
Metal reflects heat, reducing cooling costs by 10-25%.
Metal can be loud in rain/hail without proper insulation.
Shingles offer more styles; metal catching up with modern designs.
Asphalt Shingles
Pros
- Lowest upfront cost
- Easy to install and repair
- Wide variety of colors and styles
- Familiar look that appeals to buyers
- Most contractors can install them
- Quieter in rain and hail
Cons
- Shorter lifespan (20-30 years)
- More susceptible to storm damage
- Can crack in extreme cold
- May need replacement before you sell
- Not as energy efficient
Best For:
Budget-conscious homeowners, those selling within 15 years, or anyone who wants a proven, traditional look.
Metal Roofing
Pros
- Exceptional durability (40-70 years)
- Withstands extreme weather
- Energy efficient - reflects heat
- Low maintenance requirements
- Eco-friendly and recyclable
- Can be installed over existing roof
Cons
- Higher upfront cost (2-3x shingles)
- Can be noisy without insulation
- Can dent from large hail
- Fewer contractor options
- Some HOAs have restrictions
Best For:
Homeowners planning to stay long-term, those wanting minimal maintenance, or anyone prioritizing energy efficiency.
Illinois-Specific Considerations
Extreme Temperature Swings
Illinois experiences hot summers and cold winters. Metal expands and contracts but handles this well. Asphalt can crack in extreme cold but is generally reliable.
Hail & Storm Frequency
Chicagoland sees significant hail. Metal (especially steel) dents but continues to function. Asphalt shingles can crack or lose granules, shortening lifespan.
Snow Load
Metal roofs shed snow quickly, reducing ice dam risk. Shingles can trap snow but proper ventilation and ice guards help.
Insurance Considerations
Some insurers offer discounts for metal roofs due to their durability. Check with your provider before deciding.
The Bottom Line
There's no universally "better" choice.it depends on your priorities:
Choose Shingles If:
- • Upfront budget is limited
- • You may sell within 15 years
- • You prefer a traditional look
- • Noise during storms bothers you
Choose Metal If:
- • You're staying 20+ years
- • Long-term value matters most
- • You want minimal maintenance
- • Energy efficiency is a priority
Still Not Sure? Let Us Help
Our roofing experts can assess your home, discuss your goals, and recommend the best option for your specific situation.no obligation.